Saturday, December 26, 2009

In Gaza, even the walls go underground


A wall is going down at the Egypt-Gaza border - but by ‘down’, I do not mean it is falling: it is going underground. 20 to 30 meters deep, to be exact.


After unconfirmed rumours first reported by Israeli newspaper Haaretz and promptly denied by the Egyptian government, images - attributed to media-friendly smugglers - surfaced in the Egyptian press and confirmed that Egypt was indeed building an iron wall along its border with Gaza strip, aimed at blocking the multitude of tunnels that link Egyptian town Rafah with its Palestinian eponymous counterpart.

The wall will stretch for 11 kilometres long, from the Mediterranean to Israeli-controlled border point Kerem Abu Salem. It will be exclusively underground.


At a press conference Saturday, Hamas spokesperson Fawzy Barhoum was understandably very critical of the wall's construction. The construction, says Barhoum, is "American-funded and supervised. It comes in tail of the US plan that began under Bush to suffocate the 1.5 million Palestinians in Gaza, after the Zionist enemy has failed to break their will".

With US and Israeli encouragement, a nervous Egypt has been silently yet steadily contributing to the Israeli-imposed blockade by tightening its own border with Gaza. After Gazans blew up a segment of the wall in January 2008 and entered Egypt for a massive shopping spree, a new 3-meters concrete wall was built along the border. Egyptian authorities now claim that the new underground wall tightening the border is a matter of national security, to prevent weapons being smuggled into the Gaza strip. It is also actively searching for, and destroying tunnels.


“A network of several hundred tunnels”, according to the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA), brings into Gaza “a range of materials, including foodstuffs, beverages, livestock, medicines, fuel, cement, paper, spare parts and other goods”. Even zoo animals have been smuggled through the tunnels, whose owners provide a lifeline for the 1.5 million Gazans stranded in the small territory for several years now under a seemingly interminable blockade. Goods allowed entry into Gaza are in drastically short supply and tightly controlled by Israel, whose lists of goods inexplicably forbidden entry include such items as jam, toilet paper, and chickpeas.

Tunnelers are not only moved by compassion and humanitarian concerns, though - tunnels are a lucrative business. Digging a tunnel can cost several tens, maybe hundreds thousand of dollars, but it seemingly recoups its costs rapidly. At the reported going rate of $1500 to move a person, $250 per cattle head and the same per sack of goods, the tunnel covers its fixed cost, as well as the running costs - which include electricity, even telephone lines, occasionally ventilators, and a tax levied by the government authorities per shipment.


Despite the announcement of the underground barrier, tunnelers remain upbeat, vowing to dig through, or bypass the barrier altogether. "Let the Americans and the Israelis pay for the wall," said one to the Egyptian press. And if the barrier is indeed impossible to cut through, wel, "the tunnels are minimum 20 meters underground. We can make it 40 meters."

But in that event, the cost of digging will necessary increase - and consequently so will the price of smuggled goods.

A few days shy of the first anniversary of last year’s three weeks-long Israeli assault on Gaza, which killed upwards of 1400 persons including several hundred children, the Strip remains in a pitiful state. Barely any reconstruction has taken place - the tunnels offer drastically insufficient supplies of construction materials, that international organisations are not allowed to make use of by their own internal guidelines.

But the cat-and-mouse game can only go this far, and the pressure on Gaza’s Palestinians, already unsustainable, cannot be allowed to increase any further. Easing, ending the blockade is inevitable.

7 comments:

Injuntarian said...

I tend to get a little irritated when people around the world try to blame everything on the US. If Egypt is participating in the construction of this wall and it is within the border area controlled by Egypt, it is Egypt who is building it. The US can't even control its own border, so why on Earth would they be getting involved with someone else's?

Meanwhile, as we watch Barrack Obama turn his back on Israel, I can see no reason why he would authorize the continuation of this project even if the US was involved in the first place. He has the authority to cut off funding for such a project and from what we're seeing, he would do so if the US was, in fact, funding this.

If the tunnels were only used to bring in the mentioned supplies I really don't think Egypt would be so concerned about them. Unfortunately, they are big business by way of tolls for their use and movement of arms and illegal substances.

There were treaties signed decades ago which have not been upheld by any of the sides involved. Further, nobody wants to sit down and work it out. Everybody thinks their was is the only right way. I don't expect folks to hold hands around a bonfire singing "Kumbaya" but at least have the fortitude to take responsibility for yourselves and leave the US out of it.

Mo-ha-med said...

Injuntarian, you make good points, but i must disagree.
First, it is a fact that the US is 'involved in someone else's border'. Lots of other borders, actually. :)

By fact of the political, economic and military clout, its influence reaches far beyond its borders. Regarding the Egyptian border, looking at what is happening those days, trust me, there's nothing more Egypt would like than letting those demonstrators into Gaza. Unfortunately, 'gentle' coercion from the US and Israel makes Egypt close it borders when it wishes not to.
How does the coercion work? Simple. The US squeezes Egypt's balls, wagging its annual 2.1 billion dollars gift. Egypt does it is being asked to.

"as we watch Barack Obama turn his back on Israel"
i wish that was the case, I truly do. But it isn't. Obama tried to wag his finger to Israel, asking it to halt building settlements for a few months.
Now, those settlements are illegal. It shouldn't be a question of 'a few months', it should be permanent. And it shouldn't be about stopping to build new ones, it should be about removing them.

It's like - I steal your wallet and keep spending all the money in it. And then, the police asks me to suspend the spending for a couple of days - after which I can resume using your credit cards to splurge on myself.
Shouldn't the police ask me to return the wallet and the money I've spent? That would make more sense. Only that's not happening.

So anyway. Obama asks the Israelis nicely to not build new settlements in Palestine. And Israel, effectively, gives him the finger. Actually, not the finger, their whole fist.
Declaring a 'partial' suspension of building means that - guess what - they are STILL BUILDING NEW SETTLEMENTS! They are! Just yesterday, they approved the building of 700 apartments in occupied East Jerusalem! The US, of course, is still recovering from the major diplomatic slap that Israel gave it, and is standing silently.

Does that sound like 'Obama turning his back on Israel'?

Were the tunnels used to bring weapons? Most evidently, sure. But their main role - and the reason there are so many - is that, under a ban so fucking random that it includes pasta, jam and soap (and it changes all the time, too) and with the humanitarian aid that Israel allows in representing a drop in the needs of the 1.5 million people in Gaza, the tunnels become an incredibly important source of supply of what people need and want.

So this where we stand. The solution is obvious: end the occupation!

maria said...

Mo-ha-med,
I know this is not the subject of the post but I I wanted to ask you something, since you seem to know well this conflict.

I have a good friend who's starting an artistic/social project next year and he wants it to have to locations: Ramallah and Jerusalem.it's about identity and discourse elaboration. He is planning travel according to distances and not really according to checkpoints and paper/admin problems that might arise. He's not part of any ngo and an italian national. it's a personal, non political project.

So I was wandering if you knew how easy it is to get in public transport from Ramallah to Jerusalem, and what kind of problems are likely to arise.

He might be handicapped by checkpoint to the point of not being able to carry out workshops in one place or the other? will the israeli army ask why he wants to cross so many times to ocuppied territories/cisjordania?

If you have any comments it would be great.
thanks!
maria

Mo-ha-med said...

Hi Maria,
Your friend needn't worry.

Foreigners have a much easier time travelling than Palestinians do. The checkpoint on the Ramallah-East-Jerusalem route, the Kalandia (or Qalandia, depending on the spelling) checkpoint, is a massive structure which separates the West Bank from East Jerusalem and Israel. This one is actually fairly organised. Foreigners with a valid Israeli visa won't have any trouble doing the trip back and forth. I personally did it no less than three times a week. The soldiers look at your foreign passport, check that your visa is valid, and wave you through. Actually, while Palestinians have to go through the metal detectors and the giant turngates (which I describe in detail in this post) foreigners can actually stay in the bus, not needing to go out with the Palestinians. Unfair, yes, but eh.

So, he'll be fine. (sidenote: if he's got lots of piercings and has dreadlocks and the like, they might be less kind to him, assuming he's with a demonstrating/anarchist group of the International Solidarity Movement type - whom I like, but the Israelis not so much!

I hope that helps. Have your friend email me if necessary.

maria said...

thanks a lot!! It's really useful to us (actually I might go visit him while he's doing the workshops and film them so it's interesting for me to know this too)
I'll tell him all this and tell him to contact you if he needs. He is interested and works in human rights issues but his appearance is not like you describe :-)

Khaled said...

Mohammad.... I think the foreigners and the old people aren't allowed anymore to stay in the bus. Sometimes, they stay in the bus. But I've heard that it depends on the soldiers mood!!.

One more thing, I don't think that the people at the Egyptian Government do care that much about the people in Gaza. They don't have to as long as the PA doesn't care about them.... Who cares Moh? I don't even believe that the people in the west bank care enough about the Palestinians in Gaza. They are holding midnight new year celebrations and the next day you'll find out that they joined the group "Free Gaza" on Facebook.... that's all.... Our regimes and our people fuck up big time......

Mo-ha-med said...

Maria -
Ey, it had to be mentioned. :)
Have a great time there! Lucky you!

Khaled -
Really? when i was there (2008) it was still okay.
Oh shit, dude... Even the old people? The women with babies? Bastards..

Apparently, no, the Egyptian government doesn't care much about Palestinians. Shame, really.

Keep the hope up, good man. If we don't, who will?