Friday, July 31, 2009

Developing countries politicians on Facebook: Who are they?


An advert for a Gabonese political candidate popped up on my Facebook homepage, and got me asking – are developing countries politicians using Web 2.0? If so, who?


Ever since US politicians discovered Web 2.0 and started blogging, posting and tweeting (and one John Kerry thought it was a good idea to physically go to the Facebook HQ, for some reason), Politicians around the world have been catching up fast. And developing countries, unsurprisingly, are following suit – with a twist.


Besides the obvious goals of engaging with a young and often apolitical demographic, and putting a ‘human face’ on a cold public persona, social media also offers a platform for smaller candidates on a shoestring budget – with sometimes remarkable results (if not always successful).



In developing countries, where the Government often hogs the airwaves and curtails opposing and dissenting opinions, the internet serves at bypassing government control.


As such, social media has been used as a platform for expressing preferences or disagreements vis-a-vis politicians and policies they normally wouldn’t have been aired given a climate of opinion censorship, and more interestingly as a means of organising among opposition and demonstrators.

Iran’s recent ‘green’ movement comes to mind of course, but before it does Lebanon’s constant political mess , and Egypt’s ‘6th of April’ movement.


Were you there?



Developing country politicians took their time but are now getting on board, too.



I browsed through the first 1000+ “Politicians” fan pages on Facebook, looking for the developing country politicos trying to communicate via social media. That goes all the way down to Fan pages with roughly 2500 followers, which is a reasonable cutting point – below that, it’s hard to consider a group really influential.



So who are those e-politicians??



- They mainly come from middle-income countries. Unsurprising, given the necessity of a critical mass of a computer-literate audience, along with a reasonable internet penetration.


- The vast majority come from countries using a Latin-based alphabet. That I found pretty interesting, but logical: Facebook and others were only in English for the longest time. Most social media users also use English, even non-Engish-natives. Furthermore, many web clients only support the Latin alphabet.


- Some major developing countries seem to be completely absent, potentially because Facebook penetration remains limited. China, for instance, has its local and more popular equivalent website, called Xiaonei (校內). India also is a notable absence, which I fail to explain. Perhaps it’s because of the popularity of other social networking websites (notably Orkut, Hi5, and India’s own Bigadda).


- Autocracies don’t breed politicians. There are therefore no political campaigns in China or in Saudi Arabia; and since politicians in office are not accountable to their electorate, they feel no necessity to communicate with them either.

This is part of the reason why only Lebanon stands out from the Arab world with a strong online political presence (though mainly fan groups; very few politicians actually online).



Quick methodology note:

I only included pages endorsed or maintained by the politicians themselves. As such, unofficial fan or support groups were omitted. Also, all those supporting dead people, even if their supporters would vote them in from the grave, were also omitted.


I suspect many politicians have failed to reconvert into ‘Fan pages’ and still use basic profiles or groups. Those are unfortunately outside of my search area – because it would take me forever to track them down.


So without further ado..


Those are your politicians, divided by continent.

Is yours in the list??


I surely missed some – feel free to add them in the comments section.



Latin America seems to be ahead of the curve in this respect.


Sebastian Pinera('s PR team), running for Chile’s 2010, regularly posts declarations, videos and links on his page. Some people are no fans of him, for that matter.


Also in the same country, known eccentric millionaire Leonardo Farkas, sports a haircut from the eighties but calls himself the “2.0 candidate for new politics in Chile” and boasts over 300,000 supporters.

Another candidate, youthful Marco Enrique-Ominami – running on a ‘Los Jóvenes al Poder’ platform, somehow – shares personal and work updates with his supporters.


Colombia’s Segio Fajardo only puts links on his official facebook account but I’m including him because I like the guy. Smart cookie he is. He tweets, though. (and follows me, so he has to be in here).


Also in Colombia, the website of Presidential hopeful Gustavo Petro has 4 Warhol-esque pictures of himself as a banner. His facebook photo looks more like a stand-up comedian.


Still in Colombia, MP David Luna posts photos and links – my guess is he's going for an Anderson Cooper look. He ends up looking like the guy trying to sell you a set of knives for $99.99 at a 3 AM television informercial.



Mexico’s governor of the state Nayarit, Ney González Sánchez also has a page where he posts photos from his phone, uploads pretty videos of the region, and shares photos of the newborns in his family.


In Argentina, politician Gabriela Michetti just loves to upload videos of herself.


Juan Cabandié’s status was “Pensando”. Yeah, that will get you elected as Buenos Aires’ mayor alright.



In Asia:


Iran’s Mir Hossein Mousavi’s endorsed Facebook profile (and Twitter account) has been immensely active since before the elections.


Also in Iran, Reza Pahlavi – yes, that Pahlavi – has found a new breath of interest in him since the June 12 elections, and has been blogging and posting away from, ehemm, Maryland.


Malaysia has a surprisingly large number of active politicians. (Sheema, thank you!!)


Mahatir bin Mohamad maintains a blog, twitter account, and a facebook fan page.



Opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim’s facebook fan page gives a few smiling photos of him, and an RSS feed from his blog.


MP Nurul Izzah Anwar - his daughter - who blogs, facebooks (not very often though) and tweets frequently, about arbitrary executions – and finding a name for her newborn.


Opposition MP and blogoholic Lim Kit Siang loves his facebook page.


Malaysia’s “Sassy MP” (self-attributed title, I’m afraid) Teresa Kok informs us that her favourite quote is "If you want breakfast in bed, then go sleep in the kitchen."


This douche is actually an elected politician. Be afraid. Be very afraid.



MP and former minister Azalina Othman posts comments, photos, and uses a funny mix of Malay and English to communicate with readers.


Indonesia also has a decent online political presence, aside from the numerous support groups for SBY.


Indonesian politician Prabowo Subianto also has a pretty snappy facebook page which he also updates regularly with his ‘Good morning Indonesia’ notes. Megawati Soekarno’s website also endorses the same facebook page.



Rest of Asia:


Syed Mustafa Kamal (sorry, ‘Mayor Syed’) changed his fan page after elections to include his title as Mayor of Karachi. He updates his status daily, if not more often. When does he work as mayor then??


Thai prime minister Abhisit Vejajiva has an official page which he updated twice – one of them to say that “Abhisit is working hard”. Apparently, 1,506 people found it worthy of thumbs up.


Philippines’ Francis ‘Chiz’ Escudero has a page (or three) on every website that will let him have one. Facebook included, naturally.


Azerbaijani MP Ganire Pasayeva (or, in Azerbaijani, Gənirə Paşayeva) posts the occasional link on her page.


Failed Dhaka mayoral candidate Chowdhury Irad Ahmed Siddiky is still posting as often as a bored 14 year old girl.


Maldives president Mohamed Nasheed is probably the highest ranking official on this list to have an officially endorsed Facebook page (at least it seems to be).


The updates of Andra Pradesh politician Jayaprakash Narayan mainly concern his amazement at the growing number of fans. (yawn).


Sub-Saharan Africa:


Nigeria’s Lagos Governor Babatunde Raji Fashola has a facebook page where he addresses readers as ‘dear citizens of Nigeria’, though his page has been idle for several months.


Nigerian presidential candidate Pat Utomi has a very noisy website, and prefaces his videos with a green ‘Utomi TV’ banner that reminds me of the X-files. And of course a facebook page to compile all this.


Zimbabwe’s prime minister Morgan Tsavangirai’s page owes its followership, most probably, to the internationalization of the last Zimbabwean elections. Occasional messages are posted.


Bruno Ben-Moubamba, candidate for the next Gabonese presidential elections (after, it is worth remembering, Omar Bongo Ondimba’s 42-year reign) went a step further and actually bought advertising space on Facebook: his smart smiling face hence appears on the screen of some facebook users who have not expressed any particular interest for Gabonese politics.


Ledama Olekina, who hopes to win Kenya’s presidential elections in 2012, has a strangely Obamesque feel to his blog - when you see his facebook photo, you’ll know it wasn’t fortuitous.


Kenyan Minister of Tourism Najib Balala also posts and links often on his page.


She’s not a politician but I bet she will be: Kenyan businesswoman Esther Passaris posts regularly about local political issues. All she needs to do now is get rid of the photos on her blog where she looks like a renegade from Kaoma.


Ghana president John Atta Mills endorsed, during the presidential campaign, a facebook page as well. It's been idle since.


Europe:


Kosova's Albin Kurti, of the anti-UN group “Vetevendosje!” maintains an online presence. No one told him that Kosovo is already independent, perhaps. Notes are updates regularly.


Turkey has numerous support groups for all sorts of national, regional and local politicians – dead or alive. And Ataturk probably has a dozen just for himself. However, these profiles seem to never be endorsed by the politicians, who do not communicate through them with their followership. I’m surprised.


Turkey also has a noticeable number of ‘in memoriam’ fan sites, such as this one.


In the Arab world,


Queen Rania of Jordan, of course, comes ahead with more than 70,000 fans.


And her profile photo is from the day I met her. I swear.

(Wait a second as I click ‘become a fan’...)


Rania, fly away with me..


Lebanese Minister Ziyad Baroud has a page but has no updates (though I believe it is an ‘official’ page).


Lebanese opposition leader Michel Aoun may have a page here – the notes sound authoritative enough.


And Lebanese MP Misbah Ahdab updates his page regularly, though he speaks a lot to say nothing. Eh.


As for Egypt,


Opposition leader Ayman Nour is the notable online political presence – with 3700 ‘friends’. Occasional comments and links are posted.


The largest fan group however is for Amr Moussa, with nearly 5000 supporters.

The second is, surprisingly enough, for MP Hisham Talaat Mostafa, currently incarcerated for complicity to murder, with over 3100 members.

A Hosni Moubarak fan group is also there, with 1800 fans.


And to end on a more entertaining note, those are some notable profiles posted as Politicians.

Emilie Turunen is 26 and a Member of the European Parliament for Denmark, and uses smiley faces. I feel very old now.

Barack Obama’s teleprompter has 3282 supporters. Perfect punctuation sells, clearly.

Santa Claus – listed as a ‘politician’ as well – has 2500 fans, on top of his 5000 ‘friends’. With that, the man could be an MP.

William Wallace seeks freedooooooom! Online.

Montazer El Zaidy has 6500 shoe-throwers behind him.

And finally,

Louis the XXth, or the wet dream of French royalists. People address him as ‘Your Majesty’ or ‘Your Eminence’.


Wow, that was one long post.



11 comments:

talesfromethehood said...

Great post. Both entertaining (make me Queen Raina's 70,001st fan), and also throught-provoking (the web and specifically social networking platforms are dramatically underutilized in development/relief/governance overall).

NG said...

Great post! How long did it take you to track down all these groups?

Facebook is not the only web 2.0 outlet for these people, they are spreading everywhere now, mostly via Twitter!

Khaled said...

Queen Rania cares a lot about web 2.0 websites. She uses YouTube (She has won YouTube Visionary Award back in 2008), FaceBook and Twitter. She understands the power of these services very well.

Yet, I think the real power in facebook lies in the power of the people themselves. It is when you share a link or put a status which indicates your political background where the real change can come from.

BTWM, Ismail Haniyeh and Hasan Nasrallah fan pages were recently removed by facebook.

aliyah06 said...

Queen Rania of Jordan is one of my favorites...and I'm a huge fan of her YouTube videos--and you got to meet her!!? I'm jealous....

As for Reza Pahlavi, well.....Maryland isn't great but at least he isn't going to get killed blogging from there.

Mo-ha-med said...

TalesFromTheHood - Thanks!! The article was just too long though - but the utilisation of social networking definitely deserves a longer conversation...

NG - Thank you! It took me... a few days. Which is exactly what I shouldn't do when I'm supposed to have work. :))
Re: Twitter: you're very right. I wouldn't know how to track them down though.. but it could very interesting to try to make a typology of sorts.

Khaled - yeah, she does -- sometimes i think she uses it a bit too much. Do you read her twitter stream? It's cute but a little silly at times...

Re: the Haniyeh and Nasrallah pages - yeah, I followed that. Apparently, Avi Dichter and his gang have been celebrating on Facebook, too..

Aliyah06 - I did meet her! And it feels really weird to actually adress someone as "Your Majesty the Queen, I hope you're well". :)
as for Pahlavi - I don't think anyone cares much for him any longer. People may dislike the Islamic republic, but they're not keen on the royal regime either...

Sheema said...

Hey Mo-ha-med,

I check your blog from time to time (you're one of my favourite commenters over at Nizo's!), but only just came across this post somewhat belatedly.

As I'm Malaysian here's a few comments:

1) The sudden proliferation of politicians' blogs in Malaysia, ad nauseum, is due solely to the trouncing that the ruling Barisan Nasional government received in the last general elections. The overwhelming support garnered by the Opposition was due in large part to the 'alternative' media and information sources available online - people were sick of constantly being force-fed the repetitive lies and propaganda which the government-muzzled newspapers routinely dish out. Unfortunately, most of the politicians who rushed to jump on the blogging bandwagon got it wrong - they didn't realise that it was the message, not the medium, which made all the difference. People aren't going to be interested in reading your blog if you're still spewing out the same old lies and propaganda they can find in the papers. Doh.

2) You made a slight boo-boo! Both Anwar Ibrahim and Nurul Izzah (his daughter) are members of the Opposition in Malaysia, not Indonesia.

3) And lastly, don't knock Teresa Kok! (Rhyme not intended, hehe.) She may like to goof around a bit but as yet another member of the Opposition she's a fearless fighter challenging the status quo and championing justice for the ordinary people. She walks the talk, and has had to take a lot of shit for doing so. Make no mistake, her heart and brains are in the right place. :)

Rodrigo said...

The question is whether they post the updates themselves or if they have 'ghost writers' to do it...
Louis XX's fb page is trop fort!

Mo-ha-med said...

Sheema

Thank you for the insights into the Malaysian political world! So the alternative media worked that well for the Opposition..
Well if the gov decided to move to the internet, are the newspapers less polluted with government propaganda?

I put Anwar Ibrahim in Indonesia? Well I don't know Nurul Izzah but I'm fairly sure i know who AI is.. Must've reshuffled the article. Sorry - corrected!

Teresa Kok looked so... baby pink! It's hilarious! But if she's such a good politician, I'll be keeping an eye open. :)

Rodrigo
The more senior ones will have host riders. The younger, and the most pretentious, write they own shit.

And yeah, I imagine that Louis Jr Jr Jr (etc) uses his facebook fanpage to impress girls.

My First Biz said...

Mohammed, your comments on Esther Passaris photos on her blog have been noted. It is a pleasure to get constructive criticism.

NG said...

Web sites like http://wefollow.com/ can help if you decided to do write about politicians on Twitter.
:)

Mo-ha-med said...

My First Biz - I understand you manage her website. Seriously, friend, remove the photos from the 80s.

NG - Hmmm, point taken! I'll give it a thought - though i really shouldn't get into another one of those massive posts any time soon, too much work.... but thank you!!